Air Pollution In India And Challenges In Pollution Control

Source: Indian Express
GS III: Environmental Pollution and Degradation


Overview

  • India’s air pollution response remains focused on seasonal interventions rather than addressing long-term pollution sources and ensuring sustained accountability.
  • Temporary restrictions often impose disproportionate economic costs on daily-wage workers, small businesses and vulnerable communities.
  • Fragmented governance, weak enforcement and lack of inter-state coordination hinder effective pollution management, highlighting the need for an airshed-based approach.
  • Despite initiatives such as NCAP, CAQM and GRAP, India needs year-round pollution control, stronger implementation and socially inclusive policies to ensure clean air.

Why in the News?

An opinion article in The Indian Express highlights India’s inadequate approach to air pollution.

News in Brief

  • India’s response to air pollution remains largely focused on monitoring the Air Quality Index (AQI) and undertaking temporary measures rather than addressing long-term sources of pollution.
  • Seasonal interventions such as anti-smog guns, mist cannons, green nets and road vacuum cleaning create an appearance of action without necessarily improving air quality.
  • Pollution-control measures often disproportionately affect daily-wage workers, small businesses and other economically weaker sections.
  • Fragmented governance, inadequate coordination between states and the mismatch between airsheds and political boundaries weaken India’s pollution-control efforts.
Pollution control has become a seasonal ritual

  • Air pollution, particularly in Delhi-NCR, receives significant attention during winter when AQI levels deteriorate.
  • However, the focus remains on daily AQI monitoring rather than building long-term accountability for pollution control.
  • Measures such as the following often create an impression of action without addressing underlying causes;
    • Sprinkling water through mist cannons.
    • Installing anti-smog guns.
    • Covering construction sites with green nets.
    • Using road vacuum cleaners.
    • Conducting plantation drives without ensuring the survival of saplings.
  • Waste management and plantation programmes also suffer from poor implementation and inadequate maintenance.
  • Pollution control must move beyond seasonal emergency responses towards continuous environmental management.
Disproportionate impact on the poor

  • Pollution-control restrictions frequently impose economic costs on vulnerable sections of society.
  • A 15-day CAQM ban on construction activities ahead of Diwali, which reportedly affected around 70% of daily-wage labourers in places such as Gurugram and Manesar without adequate financial relief.
  • Restrictions on small fires and the use of polluting fuels also affect small businesses and eateries.
  • Work-from-home arrangements and restrictions on vehicle usage may be easier for salaried employees but difficult for informal workers and people whose livelihoods depend on mobility.
  • Environmental regulations should not transfer the cost of pollution control disproportionately to economically weaker sections.

Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM)

  • Established through the Commission for Air Quality Management in National Capital Region and Adjoining Areas Act, 2021.
  • A statutory body under the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change.
  • Coordinates and monitors air pollution control measures in Delhi-NCR and adjoining areas.
  • Can issue directions and coordinate with state governments and other authorities.
  • Addresses pollution sources such as industries, vehicles, construction activities and agricultural residue burning.
Seasonal disruptions instead of structural solutions

  • Every winter, pollution control becomes focused on identifying seasonal contributors such as stubble burning, firecracker emissions, construction dust, and seasonal weather conditions.
  • These factors contribute to pollution episodes, but focusing exclusively on them diverts attention from year-round pollution  sources.
  • Long-term industrial emissions, transport pollution, waste burning and energy consumption also require sustained attention.
  • Pollution cannot be controlled through temporary restrictions when its underlying sources remain unaddressed throughout the year.
Environmental Measures and Social Inequality

  • India has significant socio-economic inequalities, which influence people’s ability to respond to environmental regulations.
  • Work-from-home arrangements protected sections of the workforce while exposing ordinary workers to health risks and economic costs.
  • A similar pattern is visible in pollution control, where restrictions on mobility and economic activities affect different social groups unequally.
  • Environmental policies must incorporate livelihood protection and social justice.
Government initiatives and their implications

  • The government has introduced several initiatives to address air pollution, including:
    • Clean Energy Transition: Promoting cleaner energy sources to reduce dependence on polluting fuels.
    • Electric Vehicle Transition: Encouraging electric mobility to reduce vehicular emissions.
    • National Clean Air Programme (NCAP): Addressing air pollution in more than 100 cities.
    • Industrial Transition: Encouraging industries to adopt cleaner fuels and relocating highly polluting industrial units.
  • However, the experts raises concerns regarding:
    • Whether these initiatives are adequately scaled up.
    • Whether states possess sufficient administrative and financial capacity to implement them.
    • Whether existing schemes can achieve measurable improvements in air quality.
    • Whether environmental protection receives sufficient political attention beyond Delhi-NCR.
Federalism and the Airshed Approach

  • Air pollution does not follow administrative or political boundaries.
  • An airshed is a geographical area within which pollutants move and affect air quality through atmospheric processes.
  • The boundaries of airsheds often extend across multiple states and jurisdictions.
  • However, pollution-control policies are largely implemented within individual administrative boundaries.
  • States may shift the responsibility and economic costs of pollution to neighboring regions rather than collectively addressing the problem.
  • Air pollution requires coordination and airshed-based planning rather than isolated state-level interventions.
Limitations of the Parivartan Scheme

  • Under the Parivartan scheme, the government provides subsidies to replace commercial vehicles with BS-VI-standard vehicles or transition towards cleaner transportation.
  • However:
    • The scheme is confined to the National Capital Region (NCR).
    • Around 56,000 vehicles had been registered under the scheme.
    • Only a few hundred operators had actually availed themselves of the subsidy.
    • The subsidy was reportedly insufficient to make vehicle conversion financially viable.
  • This highlights the gap between policy announcements and actual implementation.
  • Incentives must be financially attractive and accessible to achieve large-scale adoption of cleaner technologies.
Government Initiatives to Control Air Pollution

Initiative Key Features
National Clean Air Programme (NCAP), 2019 Aims to improve air quality through city-specific action plans.
Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM), 2021 Coordinates air pollution management in Delhi-NCR and adjoining areas.
Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP) Introduces emergency pollution-control measures based on AQI levels in Delhi-NCR.
National Air Quality Monitoring Programme (NAMP) Monitors ambient air quality across the country.
FAME India Scheme Promotes electric and hybrid vehicles.
PM-Ebus Sewa Supports the deployment of electric buses in cities.
SATAT Initiative Promotes compressed biogas production from agricultural and organic waste.
UJALA Scheme Promotes energy-efficient LED lighting to reduce electricity consumption.
Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana Promotes LPG connections to reduce household air pollution from traditional cooking fuels.
Challenges in India’s Air Pollution Management

  • India faces several challenges in managing air pollution.
  • Fragmented governance and overlapping responsibilities among multiple agencies weaken effective implementation, while the lack of regional coordination makes it difficult to control pollutants that travel across state boundaries.
  • Weak enforcement of environmental regulations, inadequate public transport, waste-management facilities and pollution-monitoring infrastructure further aggravate the problem.
  • Moreover, pollution-control restrictions often impose a disproportionate economic burden on daily-wage workers and vulnerable communities.
  • The excessive dependence on temporary emergency measures, insufficient financial incentives for adopting cleaner technologies and limited political attention to pollution outside severe episodes also hinder sustained progress.
Way Forward and Conclusion

India should adopt an airshed-based approach, strengthen institutional coordination, expand public transport and promote cleaner industrial and vehicular technologies. Pollution control must focus on year-round prevention, scientific monitoring and better urban planning.

A just transition should protect vulnerable workers through financial and livelihood support. Clean air must be treated as a continuous public health priority rather than a seasonal concern.


Daily Current Affairs: Click Here

Rate this Article and Leave Feedback
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x